Load profile and single-line diagram on an engineer’s monitors, with a power-quality meter and calculations on the desk
Power systems10 November 2026·9 min read

Load-flow, short-circuit and protection coordination studies explained

A drawing of your electrical network does not show how it behaves under load or in a fault. Power system studies do, and they decide whether a design is safe.

In this article
  1. The model that all studies share
  2. Load flow: how the system behaves normally
  3. Fault level: how big a fault can get
  4. Short circuit: what happens in a fault
  5. Protection coordination: making the right device operate
  6. The studies built on the same model
  7. The data that a study needs
  8. What the owner receives
  9. How AVEX GRID helps

Key points

  • A load flow study shows voltages, currents and losses in normal running, and whether any equipment is overloaded.
  • A short circuit study shows how much fault current flows at each point. This sets the ratings of switchgear and the settings of protection.
  • A protection coordination study makes sure the device nearest a fault trips first, so the rest of the plant keeps running.
  • Arc flash and motor starting studies use the same model. They cover worker safety and the effect of big motor starts on the supply.
  • A study is only as good as its data. If cable lengths and nameplates are guessed, the results are guesses too.

Most plant owners meet power system studies as a demand from someone else. A lender asks for them. The utility wants them before it allows a connection. An insurer asks for them after an incident. A better way to see them is as the way an engineer checks an electrical system before it is built or changed, just as a structural engineer checks a building. This article explains the main studies, what each one answers and how they fit together.

The model that all studies share

Every study starts with a model of your network. The engineer draws a single-line diagram. This is done in analysis software such as ETAP, which engineers use to model and study electrical power systems. The engineer then enters the data for each part. That means the utility supply and its fault level, the transformers with their ratings, the cables with their size and length, the generators and motors, the loads, the capacitor banks and the protective devices.

Once the model is built and checked, the engineer runs different calculations on the same data. So every result is only as accurate as the model. Most of the effort in a study usually goes into collecting and checking the data.

Two IEEE standards are the long-standing references. IEEE Standard 399, known as the Brown Book, covers industrial and commercial power system analysis. It includes load flow. It also covers short circuit, so a very large current flows. It covers motor starting too. It covers harmonics, LED lights and inverters. And it covers protection coordination. IEEE Standard 242, the Buff Book, deals with choosing, applying and coordinating protective devices. Both are recommended practices. Engineers use them alongside current IEC and IEEE standards for specific calculations.

Load flow: how the system behaves normally

A load-flow study calculates the steady condition of the network for a given set of loads and generation. It finds the voltage at every busbar, the current and power in every cable or transformer, and the losses. It also finds the real power and the reactive power. Reactive power is the power that motors and transformers use to build their magnetic fields. It does no useful work, but it still loads cables and transformers.

The questions it answers are practical:

  • Are any cables or transformers loaded beyond their ratings?
  • Do voltages at the ends of long feeders stay within the permitted band, usually within a few percent of the nominal voltage?
  • How much energy is lost in cables and transformers?
  • Where is reactive power needed, and how big should a capacitor bank be? A capacitor bank is a set of capacitors that supply reactive power on site. It lifts the power factor and cuts the extra charge on your bill. Power factor shows how much of the power you draw is actually useful. A figure of 1.00 is perfect, and motors, transformers and welders pull it down.

The study is run for several scenarios. These include maximum load, minimum load, with and without generation, and with the largest transformer or feeder out of service. For a solar plant, the scenarios include full output at low load. Then power flows backwards towards the grid, and the study checks the effect on voltage. The same study shows whether an existing plant can take an extra load or a new generator. It is also the foundation of a grid connection application.

Fault level: how big a fault can get

A short circuit is a fault where almost nothing limits the current. The only limit is the impedance (electrical resistance to the flow) between the source and the fault. The fault level, in MVA, tells you how much power a fault can deliver at a point in your network. You use it to choose breakers, fuses and switchgear that can survive and clear the worst fault. It lets you rate and compare equipment without naming a voltage.

Worked exampleA 1 MVA transformer with 5% impedance cannot deliver more than 1 ÷ 0.05 = 20 MVA of fault level at its secondary. On a 400 V secondary that is about 28.9 kA. A real network adds impedance and lowers the figure, but the transformer alone shows why a small change in its impedance moves the rating of every breaker downstream.

Engineers often work in a common scale called per unit, so that equipment at different voltage levels can be added together in one study. You do not need to do this yourself. It is what the study software does behind the scenes.

Short circuit: what happens in a fault

A short-circuit study calculates the current that would flow if a fault happened at each point in the network. The utility, the generators and the motors all feed current into a fault. The result at each busbar is the largest current the equipment must withstand and switch off. IEC 60909 is the international method for calculating short-circuit currents in three-phase systems. ANSI and IEEE methods are also widely used.

The results are used straight away:

  • Circuit breakers and fuses must have an interrupting rating above the fault current at their location.
  • Switchgear and busbars must withstand the mechanical and heat stress of the fault for as long as it takes to clear.
  • Cable sizes must be checked against the heating that a fault causes.
  • The fault levels set the protection settings and the arc-flash energy.

The study often shows that a plant that has grown over the years has outgrown its switchgear. Adding generators, a solar plant or a bigger transformer raises the fault level. A breaker that was fine when it was installed may now be unable to switch the current off safely. Finding this on paper costs far less than finding it in a real fault.

Maximum fault current at a transformer secondaryKiloamperes, 1,000 kVA 415 V transformer on a strong supply
34.8 kA
Transformer impedance 4%
27.8 kA
5%
23.2 kA
6%
17.4 kA
8%

Rated current 1,391 A divided by the impedance. Motors and generators add to the fault, and a real study uses the supply fault level. Source: AVEX GRID calculation.

Protection coordination: making the right device operate

When a fault happens, the protective device closest to it should clear it, and the rest of the plant should stay running. This is called selectivity, or coordination. A coordination study plots the time-current curves of relays, fuses and breakers on one graph. It then sets them so that each upstream device is slower than the one downstream of it by a safe margin. They must still be fast enough to protect cables, transformers and motors from damage. The settings are issued as a schedule, and the commissioning engineer applies them to the relays.

A plant without a coordination study often has relays on their factory settings. A fault on a small circuit can then trip the main incomer and shut down the whole site. Poor coordination can also leave equipment unprotected. A setting that is too slow lets a fault burn for longer than the equipment can stand. When a generator or solar plant connects to the grid, the utility will review the protection settings as a condition of connection.

The studies built on the same model

Several more studies reuse the model.

  • Arc flash. This study calculates the heat energy a worker would be exposed to at each piece of equipment. It uses the fault current and the clearing time from the coordination study, following the IEEE 1584-2018 method. It produces warning labels and working-distance instructions. It often leads to protection changes that shorten the clearing time. We discuss it in our article on arc-flash and ETAP studies.
  • Motor starting. This study checks the voltage dip when a large motor starts, and whether the supply and the other loads can cope. It is the basis for choosing soft starters and drives.
  • Harmonics. This study looks at the distortion that drives and rectifiers create, and whether it goes over the limits of IEEE 519.
  • Transient stability. This applies to plants with large generators or motors. It shows how they respond to sudden disturbances.

The data that a study needs

As the owner, you can speed up a study and make it more accurate by collecting information in advance. The core list is:

  • the single-line diagram;
  • the utility's fault level at the point of connection;
  • nameplate data of transformers, generators and large motors;
  • cable types, sizes and lengths;
  • the make and settings of protective devices;
  • the load list with operating patterns.

For an existing plant, a site survey checks the drawings. The plant as built differs from the drawings more often than owners expect. Measurements add confidence. A power-quality logger on the main incomer gives real loads. Thermal imaging, described in our article on thermal imaging, finds the weak connections that the model cannot show.

What the owner receives

A good study report is written to be used. It contains the model assumptions, the results for each scenario, a list of findings with their priority, and a set of recommendations. The recommendations cover equipment to replace or upgrade, settings to change and operating limits to keep to. For protection, you get a settings schedule and the coordination curves. For safety, you get arc-flash labels. The recommendations are costed where possible, so management can decide what to do first. The report also serves other parties. The utility, the lender and the insurer each use it to satisfy themselves that the plant is safe and adequate.

How AVEX GRID helps

  • Load-flow and short-circuit studies. We model your network, test it under realistic scenarios and show where it is overloaded or under-rated.
  • Protection coordination and settings. We set the protection, issue the settings schedule and support commissioning.
  • Arc-flash, motor-starting and harmonic studies. We extend the same model to safety, starting and power quality, and we prepare the labels and reports.

What AVEX GRID can take off your hands

AVEX GRID is an engineer-led energy consultancy in Zimbabwe. We do the technical work that turns an energy investment into a plant that is licensed, connected, financed and performing, whether you are a local operator or an investor overseas.

Feasibility and bankable studiesYield, load and hybrid models, and the technical file lenders and ZERA read.
Power-system engineering (ETAP)Load flow, short circuit, arc flash and protection studies for approvals and safe design.
Licence and PPA technical supportZERA licence documents, ZETDC connection studies, PPA technical schedules.
Owner's engineerDesign review, testing and commissioning on your side of the EPC table.
Tariff, audit and compliance workMaximum-demand and power-factor savings, readiness for energy-management rules.
Remote plus on the groundModelling for overseas teams, with an engineer in Zimbabwe for site, utility and regulator work.

We quote fixed prices after a free scoping call and reply the same working day.

Frequently asked questions

When does a plant need these studies?

When it is designed, when it is extended, when generation such as solar is connected, when a utility, lender or insurer asks, and after a serious fault.

What is the difference between load flow and short circuit?

Load flow shows normal operation: voltages, currents and losses under load. Short circuit shows the fault current that flows when something fails.

What data do you need from us?

The single-line diagram, the utility fault level, nameplate data, cable details, protection settings and the load list. We verify them on site where we can.

How long does a study take?

It depends on the size of the network and the quality of the data. Most of the time goes to collecting and checking data, so preparation shortens the programme.

Topics: load flow studyshort circuit studyprotection coordination studyETAP study ZimbabweIEEE 399IEC 60909power system analysisenergy consultant Zimbabwe

Sources and notes

General information to help you plan. The rules that apply to your site are confirmed by AVEX GRID against the current gazetted text, ZERA and ZETDC as part of the work. The sources used are listed below.

DJ

Devine Tafara Javangwe is the founder and lead consulting engineer at AVEX GRID. He holds an MSc in Electrical Power Engineering (Southern Federal University, 2025), is a Professional Member of the Zimbabwe Institution of Engineers and an IEEE member.

About the practice · Contact

See how your network behaves before it fails.

Send us your single-line diagram and equipment list. We scope the studies, tell you what they will find and give a fixed price.

+263 78 488 9775 · Autherstone Street 21, Marondera, Zimbabwe · Remote across Southern Africa